THE Supreme Court has ordered the reassignment of Judge Kenneth L. Govendo from the Family Court for a period of one year as part of his public censure for using œracially inappropriate language in three cases.
Govendo was also ordered to write a letter of apology to the people of the commonwealth and to complete an off-island educational program on judicial ethics œat his own expense.
Govendo declined to comment.
The Supreme Court said the judge must submit his letter of apology for its review and approval within 15 days, and will œbear the expense of taking out advertisements in two newspapers of local circulation in order to ensure that the letters are published in its entirety.
Associate Justice Alexandro C. Castro and Justices Pro Tem Edward Manibusan and Vern P. Perez signed the slip opinion that was released yesterday. (See http://www.justice.gov.mp/documents/2010%20MP%2016.pdf)œTo ensure a smooth transition, [Govendos] reassignment shall be done at the direction of Presiding Judge Robert C. Naraja within 60 days, the Supreme Court ordered.
The Supreme Court said œthe National Judicial Colleges Ethics, Fairness, and Security in Your Courtroom and Communityis highly recommended. Judge Govendo may petition the court to take a different course that may be offered earlier by a different institution, but an online class will not be accepted.
In the recommended class, œparticipants will examine real cases and use hypothetical scenarios to distinguish between proper and improper personal conduct in the courtroom and community activities.
It will also œdiscuss the importance of different cultures in the community and their impact on courtrooms; reduce bias and prejudice to maintain the integrity of the court process and apply appropriate personal security measures when engaging with the public.
œAny other class that Judge Govendo would rather take should be similar to the class described above, the Supreme Court ordered.
The court at the same time acknowledged Govendos œlargely positive tenure on the Superior Court.
Govendo won national recognition for his work as a family court judge, and Presiding Judge Naraja and Associate Judge Ramona V. Manglona, who filed the complaint against Govendo, testified that he was a well-liked and respected member of the judiciary.
But the court said it listened to the recordings from the adoption cases presided by Govendo andœwe found that [his] tone in these proceedings was mean, condescending, and mad. We listened to Judge Govendo berate would-be adoptive parents on the basis that they were motivated to adopt the children not because they loved them, but instead because they wished to bring more Filipinos into the commonwealth. Judge Govendo attacked the petitioners and their motivations.
Govendo said it was the petitioners intent in these adoption proceedings to circumvent commonwealth law, and that he would not stand for such tactics.
According to the Supreme Court, œIt was not only what Judge Govendo said, but how he said it that concerned us.
The court added, œIn a nutshell, these tapes cast serious doubt as to Judge Govendos ability to maintain the proper judicial decorum. Therefore, [even though] Judge Govendos witnesses were supportivethe tapes were not favorable.
The Supreme Court found that Govendo made statements in three different cases which violated the Commonwealth Code of Judicial Conduct and the Commonwealth Rules of Judicial Disciplinary Procedure.The Supreme Court said Govendo used racially inappropriate language in two adoption proceedings involving Filipinos, and threatened a Filipino citizen with criminal prosecution and deportation.
On Oct. 15, 2010, Govendo apologized for saying œadios muchacho to a convicted stalker and domestic violence offender, but added that he shouldnt be branded racially insensitive for failing to œwalk the tightrope of political correctness.
œI apologize to any Filipino or Chamorro [offended by the remark]. I had no thought that [˜muchacho] could be interpreted as a derogatory, disparaging remark, Govendo told the Supreme Court.
Article source: http://www.mvariety.com/2010120132435/local-news/govendo-removed-from-family-court.php
No Tag
Halo Sobat, Nama Saya Sofyan Syah, Memulai Dunia Blogging Sejak Nov 2011, Meskipun Masih Baru terjun di Dunia Blogging, Saya tidak patah semangat Untuk menjadi Yang terbaik dari yang Terbaik, karena saya yakin, Tidak ada hal yang tidak Mungkin.Buat saya Blogging Is My Life.Senang rasanya jika sobat sudah Berkunjung di blog ini.
Judge govendo is a victim of ignorant and colonial minded filipinos.I am a full blooded pinoy and was previleged to study spanish during my college days. I agree with the judge that he meant 'goodbye young guy'when he made his remark in spanish.To claim that filipinos are really globally competent workforce then the controversial statement should be taken on its global and original english translation; not on its hybrid meaning for the Filipinos or chamoros that Judge Govenco may be unaware of.
Global gregorio